I just wasted an hour seriously overcomplicating this. I got the same answer of minimum questions, but a maximum of 10, starting with asking the person the person on the left, "
×You need to determine who is the Guard or Stalwart. Once you've done that, you only need to ask one question -- "
is the Lucky Greckle in Fetch the Pie? -- to one or the other. Who you are speaking to will determine where you look.
Okay, so minimum number of questions...
There are six possible ways they could be standing:
Combo 1: GNS
Combo 2: GSN
Combo 3: NGS
Combo 4: NSG
Combo 5: SNG
Combo 6: SGN
For simplicity's sake, I'm going to call them Leftie, Middleman and Rightie.
Ask Leftie "
Who are you?"
Ask Middleman "
Who is Leftie?"
Ask Rightie "
Who is Leftie?"
Possible Responses:
Click here to view the secret text
×Combo 1 "GNS" Possible Responses:
NGG
NNG
NSG
SGG
SNG
SSG
Combo 2 "GSN" Possible Responses:
SGG
SGN
SGS
NGG
NGN
NGS
Combo 3 "NGS" Possible Responses:
NGN
NSN
SGN
SSN
GGN
GSN
Combo 4 "NSG" Possible Responses:
NNG
NNS
SNG
SNS
GNG
GNS
Combo 5 "SNG" Possible Responses:
SSN
SSG
SGN
SGG
SNN
SNG
Combo 6 "SGN" Possible Responses:
SGS
SNS
SGG
SNG
SGN
SNN
Once you sort these out there are 19 distinct answers, which fall into 4 Groups. Those answers follow, along with what can be determined from them:
Group 1 - Responses that determine everyone’s identity:
Click here to view the secret text
×NSG - Leftie must be the Guard, Middleman must be the Negotiator and Rightie is the Stalwart
NGS - Leftie must be the Guard, Middleman is the Stalwart and Rightie is the Negotiator
NSN - Leftie must be the Negotiator, Middleman must be the Guard and Rightie must be the Stalwart
NNS - Leftie must be the Negotiator, Middleman must be the Stalwart and Rightie must be the Guard
GGN - Leftie must be the Negotiator, Middleman must be the Guard and Rightie must be the Stalwart
GSN - Leftie must be the Negotiator, Middleman must be the Guard and Rightie must be the Stalwart
GNG - Leftie must be the Negotiator, Middleman must be the Stalwart and Rightie must be the Guard
GNS - Leftie must be the Negotiator, Middleman must be the Stalwart and Rightie must be the Guard
Group 2 - Responses that determine who is a Stalwart or Guard:
Click here to view the secret text
×NGG - Leftie must be the Guard
Group 3 - Responses that don't determine anyone's identity for certain, but narrow Leftie's down to two possible characters:
Click here to view the secret text
×NNG - Leftie could be either the Guard or the Negotiator.
NGN - Leftie could be either the Guard or the Negotiator
SSN - Leftie could either be the Stalwart or the Negotiator
SGG - Leftie could be either the Guard or the Stalwart.
SSG - Leftie could be either the Guard or the Stalwart.
SGS - Leftie could be either the Guard or the Stalwart
SNS - Leftie could be either the Stalwart or the Negotiator
SNN - Leftie could be either the Stalwart or the Guard
Group 4 - Responses that do not identify anyone or narrow down Leftie's character:
Click here to view the secret text
×SGN - Leftie could be anyone
SNG - Leftie could be anyone
So from this we see that it is
possible to identify either a Guard or Stalwart with only three questions. Once that happens, you need ask only one more question: Is the Lucky Greckle in Fetch the Pie? Since you know if you are addressing the Guard or the Stalwart, the answer you get will tell you where to look.
Answer: 4 questions are the
minimum number of questions required to determine in which hold the Lucky Greckle is hidden, but only if you were lucky enough to get a response that fell in Group 1 or 2.
Just because I had nothing better to do, I worked out the maximum number of questions required.
Click here to view the secret text
×If you receive a response from Group 3, another round of questions is required.
Ask Leftie "Who is Rightie?"
Ask Middleman "Who is Rightie?"
Ask Rightie "Who are you?"
I won’t go through all the permutations here, but this answer -- combined with the first response -- can be used to either identify everyone one, or at least single out the Guard or the Stalwart.
If however you got an answer from Group 4 -- SGN or SNG -- and asked the 2nd round of questions, you might get an answer that would allow you to identify everyone, or at least the Guard or Stalwart, or you could get another undetermined. In which case, you need to ask a 3rd round of 3 questions:
Ask Leftie "Who is Middleman?"
Ask Middleman "Who are you?"
Ask Rightie " Who is Middleman?"
This round will determine at least who is the Guard or Stalwart, if not who everyone is. At that point, you can ask either the Guard or Stalwart "Is the Lucky Greckle in Fetch the Pie?" to know where to look.
The maximum number of questions required to determine where to look is 10.
Note: I'm sure that even if this correct, there was probably a much simpler way to do this.