eytanz wrote:
First, All carbonated drinks contain carbonic acid, not just coke.
Correct. So beware that seemingly docile can of carbonated drink!
Second, carbonic acid is a weak acid (ph around 3). The gastric acid in our stomach has a PH of around 1; our digestive tracks can handle any acid weaker than that without trouble.
Actually, that's not entirely true, I don't think. Carbonic acid is weak (It only dissociates partially), but in a can of carbonated drink, it's very highly concentrated, since they force more CO
2 into it than can be dissolved into it at atmospheric pressure (hence the fizziness), thus decreasing the pH of it to about 2-3. Stomach acid has a pH of around 1-2, so you are correct to say that this acid will not damage the lining of your stomach on contact, but since there is more acid in your stomach, it makes it much harder to fully neutralise it all when it passes into your small intestine.
Fresh orange or lemon juice is considerably more acidic than coke, yet no one goes around saying it's harmful to the digestive tract.
If you drank fresh lemon juice in large quantities of around 1-2 litres a day, I'm pretty sure that it certainly won't be very good for your digestive tract after a while.
____________________________
Resident Medic/Mycologist