×First time keep killing roaches near by wall-obstacle

×keep killing roaches in two-tile wide passage

×
Goblin room (W) - my favourite: a goblin manipulation puzzle with a twist (well no twists, but you know what I mean). Could still, IMO, do with a few more checkpoints: specifically, somewhere between killing the first snake and starting the approach to the second. ie. one of the squares in the room containing (29,12).
Tar room (NW) - was meant to be there any more to this than 'get rid of all the tar'? OK, getting rid of all the tar without rotating your sword is non-trivial, but still, it was, for me, definitely the easiest room.
Roaches (N) - another good room; though the new checkpoint makes it a bit more obvious where you are meant to go (whether this is a good thing or a bad one is debatable; for me that was the hard part of this room so maybe put a 'decoy' checkpoint somewhere else?
Wraithwing room (NE) - much better with checkpoints; not my favourite room but not bad either. This room, and the tar room, feel a tad uninspired - as if you've decided that these rooms are going to have these themes, without any idea of how you're going to do that. But, still better than many 'uninspired' rooms Not saying they are bad rooms, just not as good as the rest of the hold.
Eyes and guards (SW) - hard, but fun. My second favourite of the eight.
Seep and serpent (S); Brained roaches (SE); Golems and serpents (E) - all three good rooms; no particular comments.