eytanz wrote:
There's a big difference between saying "Dogs can understand numbers" and "dogs can, after a lot of training, be brought to a stage in which they can understand some things about numbers".
Who said that "
Dogs can understand numbers"
?
I think the mathematics trick in question was just that - a trick. I'm not sure how it was done, but since there are 20 possible answers, I wouldn't be surprised if there were 20 hand signals the dog had been taught to bark X number of times. Or one hand signal that was repeated X times. It could be a very subtle signal - a small twitch of a finger, for example, so audiences wouldn't see it.
As for the original post about dogs, b0rsuk's point was, and I quote "
They are quite good at recognizing words."
They're actually better at reading body language than they are at recognizing words, and they're great pattern learners.
what does it mean that a chimp tries to "talk" with dogs or cats? Is it really using anything resembling words? Or just trying to make sounds to elicit a response? No one really knows
I think the original poster was probably referring to primates who are taught sign language attempting to sign to other animals. There was a story I saw recently about Koko, an ape who has a vocabulary of over 1000 words in sign language. She began signing "
pain"
and then pointing to her mouth. They even constructed a pain chart with a scale from 1 to 10, and when she repeatedly pointed to 9 or 10, they gave her a dental exam and found a tooth that needed to be pulled.
Cocker-spaniel Denver from England has been trained to help crippled people can do shopping, exchange lavatory paper, bed sheets, hand over the earphone... and sort the mail. No one taught him to sort the mail, but he does it by name lenght.
I never heard about this, but I'd like to see a precise description of what the dog could do before interpreting this. My dog, when she was young, knew how to change tv channels. That doesn't mean she knew what tv channels were, only that she could make the room quieter by stepping on the remote control.
Dogs are certainly trained as service dogs to assist handicapped people. I don't see what the big deal is with any of these things - well, except maybe sorting mail by address length, that seems far-fetched (pardon the pun).
Training a dog to retrieve a phone when it rings would be relatively easy. A far cry from "
Sit"
, but it would be very do-able. Changing the toilet paper on command? Assuming you have a special toilet paper holder, such that a dog could just grab the empty roll and drop a new one in it's place - again, complicated but very possible. The dog doesn't care why the person wants these things, his thought process would be more like "
When that thing makes that funny noise, if I bring it to that person, I get a treat and petted."
Behavior that is reinforced will be repeated. I've got a dog who will, on command, take a bunch of items out of a tiny shopping cart (he's a tiny dog, so the cart has to be tiny). He doesn't understand what shopping is, but if he were bigger and I needed assistance shopping, he could do it.
I've seen that dog Rico on shows before. It was pretty neat - someone scatters a bunch of items (which Rico previously knew) and from a seperate room, where the owner can't see the items or anything, the owner tells Rico to go get two randomly selected objects, and he does. Also, if there is one (and only one) unknown object and you asked him to get it, he would correctly get the unknown object, and even remember what it was called for future retrievals.
____________________________
The greatness of a nation and its moral progress can be judged by the way it treats its animals.
--
Mahatma Gandhi